S Corp vs C Corp: What It Means for Your Business

Your business structure matters a lot. Let’s explore the possibilities.

Selecting the right business structure, like S corp vs C corp (S corporation vs C corporation), is a big deal for any business owner. This choice affects how much tax you pay, the paperwork you need, and even how much personal risk you’re taking. Just like picking a car, you want a structure that fits your style, needs, and budget. In this article, we will explore the difference between S corp vs C corp status to help you decide which one works best for you. 

Owning or managing a business or an LLC is a challenging experience. There are so many elements to look at when starting a business and choosing the right formation is one of them. You need to determine how you’ll operate, where funding will come from, how you’ll take payments, and more.  

Hint: Start your business off right with a merchant discount program to help eliminate payment processing fees from the beginning.  

In this article we compare an S corp vs a C corp business structure, and what it means for your business. In the meantime, take a look at our list of 100 business ideas in case you’re seeking inspiration or simply indulging your curiosity. 

An S corp allows proprietors to report business profits directly on their tax returns. This results in dual tax liability on the same amount, as opposed to the company bearing the tax burden. Alternatively, C corps are responsible for their own tax obligations rather than those of the proprietors. It is an excellent method to safeguard your personal belongings if the company runs into difficulty. 

Comparing S corp vs C corp (S corporation vs C corporation) and picking one of the two is a big decision that shapes your business’s future. Consult with experts like lawyers or accountants to get the best fit for your LLC or business.

S corporations and C corporations: Key differences in business structure

Small business owners often favor S corps due to their “pass-through” taxation. In this business structure, the company’s profits and losses are reported on the owners’ personal tax returns, avoiding the double taxation typically associated with C corps. However, it’s essential to understand the key differences between C corp vs S corp before deciding to affect your business’s financial future. 

S corp owners are restricted to a maximum of one hundred shareholders. All shareholders must be citizens or residents of the United States. In addition, S corps are restricted to issuing a single type of stock. This restricts their ability to raise capital. 

Conversely, C corps are regarded as distinct legal entities. This means that they are obligated to pay taxes on their business gains, and proprietors may be subject to additional taxation on their earnings. This phenomenon is known as double taxation. However, C corps afford greater autonomy in terms of control and stock options. They are permitted to hold an unlimited number of shares, including foreign ones, and to distribute various varieties of stock.  

This flexibility can make C corps more appealing to businesses planning to raise capital through stock sales or attract diverse investors. 

Both S corps and C corps provide limited liability protection, safeguarding the owners’ personal assets from business debts and liabilities. They share similar legal requirements for formation, such as filing specific documents with the state and creating corporate bylaws. 

When debating S corp vs C corp, remember that regardless of your choice, your business needs an effective way to take payments. Payment processing is an integral element of conducting business. Download our e-book for more information.

Let’s take a look at five factors that differentiate the business structure when comparing s corps and c corps:

• Taxation 
• Formation and ownership 
• Funding  
• Operations  
• Liability Protection 
• Conversion and restructuring 

1. Taxation: Pass-through vs double taxation in S corporations and C corporations

Understanding the taxation dynamics when comparing S corp vs C corp is crucial for business owners, as it directly impacts their financial obligations and business strategy.

S corporation taxation (pass-through taxation)

S corps have a structure that passes the company’s income, losses, deductions, and credits directly to the shareholders’ personal tax returns. This way, the corporation itself does not pay taxes at the corporate level.  

Instead, the profits and losses are reported and taxed at the individual shareholders’ income tax rates. This approach avoids the double taxation commonly associated with C corps. An S corp is generally more tax-efficient, especially for smaller businesses, as it allows the business owners to offset their income with the company’s losses, potentially reducing their overall tax liability. 

C corporation taxation (double taxation)

C corps experience double taxation where the corporation itself is taxed on its profits at the corporate tax rate. If a C corp decides to distribute dividends to its shareholders, these dividends are taxed again on the shareholders’ personal income tax returns. They have no restrictions on the number or type of shareholders, and can even have foreign shareholders along with issuing multiple classes of stock. This makes them a preferable choice for businesses looking to expand or go public.

2. Formation, ownership, and shareholders in corporation vs C corporation

Forming an S corp vs C corp or any kind of LLC involves distinct processes and considerations. Typically, there are 10 steps to starting a business. The choice of staring an S corp or C corp can alter what the process looks like. It can also impact ownership, shareholders, and business tax record keeping.

Formation process

C corp formation:  

Forming a C corp starts with filing Articles of Incorporation with the state. This structure is the default when a business is incorporated. In addition to these articles, C corps must appoint a registered agent and create corporate bylaws. This entity type is known for its ability to attract venture capital, making it suitable for large-scale operations. 

S corp formation:  

To form an S corp, a business must first incorporate as a C corp and then elect S corp status by filing IRS Form 2553, signed by all shareholders. This election must comply with specific IRS requirements, including limitations on the number and type of shareholders. S corps are known for pass-through taxation, making them appealing to smaller businesses seeking tax efficiency.

Recap advantages and disadvantages

C corp advantages:  

The primary advantages of a C corp include the ability to raise capital more easily through stock sales, no shareholder limit, and the possibility of attracting a wide range of investors, including international ones. 

S corp advantages:  

S corps benefits from pass-through taxation, meaning profits and losses are reported on individual shareholders’ tax returns, avoiding the double taxation seen in C corps. This can be particularly advantageous for smaller businesses.

Business tax record keeping and tax checklist

Effective business tax record keeping is vital for both S corps and C corps. Maintaining accurate and detailed records ensures compliance with tax laws and efficient handling of financial matters. A comprehensive tax checklist is essential for both entity types to navigate their distinct tax obligations efficiently.

3. Funding your business: Options and implication for S corporation vs C corporation

When considering funding options for your business or LLC, it’s vital to understand the differences between an S corp vs C corp, as they can significantly impact your ability to attract funding and investors. 

S corps operate as pass-through entities. However, S corps have limitations on shareholders and types of stock. While S corps can still offer funding avenues within these constraints, certain investors may find their ownership and tax structure less appealing. 

On the other hand, C corps are subject to corporate tax rates and have no restrictions on ownership. This allows for an unlimited number of shareholders and the issuance of multiple classes of stock. These features make C corps more attractive to venture capitalists (VCs) and are particularly well-suited for raising venture capital, especially for larger-scale operations or businesses aiming to go public. Notably, the ability to offer preferred stock aligns with the expectations of many VCs. 

For example, many startups opt for C corp status when seeking VC funding because of the flexibility and broader appeal to investors. The C corp structure better supports growth and scalability, which is essential for businesses seeking significant funding to fuel their expansion plans.

4. Operational considerations: Governance and compliance in S corporation vs C corporation

Regarding the operational aspects of S corps vs C corps, there are several key factors to consider, particularly in terms of governance structure and reporting requirements.

Governance structure

Both S corps and C corps require a formal governance structure. This typically includes a board of directors and corporate officers. The board of directors is responsible for making major decisions and setting the business strategy, while the corporate officers handle the business’s day-to-day operations. This structure is essential for both types of corporations and is legally required to ensure proper management and decision-making processes.

Reporting requirements

S corps and C corps have different reporting requirements due to their distinct tax statuses. C corps faces what is known as double taxation, where the corporation pays taxes on its profits, and shareholders pay taxes again on dividends. Due to this, C corps must file a corporate tax return and report their income, expenses, and dividends paid. 

On the other hand, S corps has pass-through taxation, meaning the corporation’s profits and losses are passed directly to the shareholders’ personal tax returns. As a result, S corps do not pay taxes at the corporate level but must file an informational return. Shareholders then report their share of the profits or losses on their individual tax returns.

Compliance obligations

Both S corps and C corps must comply with various state and federal regulations, including filing annual reports, maintaining accurate records, and adhering to corporate bylaws. These compliance obligations are critical to maintaining the corporation’s legal status and smooth operation.

Influence on decision-making

The choice between an S corp vs C corp can depend on several factors, including the size of the business or LLC, the number of shareholders, and long-term business goals. For instance, S corps might be more suitable for smaller businesses looking for simpler tax structures and fewer shareholders. Meanwhile, C corps could be the choice for larger businesses or those seeking to expand through investment or public stock offerings.

5. Liability protection and asset protection in S corporation vs C corporation

When considering liability protection and asset protection for S corp and C corp, it’s important to understand how each structure offers safeguards for business owners.

Liability and asset protection of S Corporations and C Corporations:

S corps and C corps both provide substantial liability protection to its owners. Like Limited Liability Companies (LLCs), these ensure that personal assets are generally separate from business liabilities. This means that in case of legal issues or business debts, the personal assets of owners are typically protected. For instance, if an S corp or C corp faces a lawsuit, the shareholder’s personal assets and belongings are not at risk for settling business debts​​.

Real-world impact:

In real-world scenarios, the choice of corporate structure can significantly impact a business owner’s risk exposure and growth potential. For small businesses with fewer shareholders, an S corp can provide the necessary protection without the complexities of a C corp. Conversely, for businesses aiming for rapid growth or public trading, a C corp offers more flexibility in raising capital and diversifying ownership.

6. Conversion and restructuring: Flexibility in decision-making for C corporation vs S corporation

Conversion and restructuring from an S corp to a C corp, or vice versa, offer business owners flexibility in decision-making to adapt to changing business needs and goals.

Conversion benefits and considerations:

Converting from an S corp to a C corp can be driven by various factors, including seeking preferential tax rates or planning to issue qualified small business stock. For example, a business might convert to a C corp to take advantage of the Section 1202 gains exclusion under the IRS tax code, which benefits investors in C corps by allowing them to deduct qualified small business stock gains on tax returns​​.

Restructuring impacts:

When a company converts to a C corp, it faces potential double taxation, as profits are taxed at the corporate and shareholder levels. This contrasts with the single level of taxation in an S corp, where profits are taxed at individual tax rates​​. 

The decision to convert also depends on the company’s future plans, such as selling the business or raising significant capital.

Seeking professional guidance

Consultants play a pivotal role in guiding businesses through the complexities of decision-making. They bring a wealth of expertise and experience across various domains, enabling a business or LLC to make well-informed choices. These professionals cover diverse areas such as management, strategy, financial planning, information technology, and human resources, each addressing different facets of business operations and strategy. 

For instance, a management consultant specializes in developing and implementing efficient operational and management methodologies. These are geared toward maximizing overall business performance and efficacy. Strategy consultants collaborate with company leaders to align business strategies and enhance existing ones. They provide valuable insights into budgets, operations, and overall business performance. Financial consultants offer crucial advice on optimizing financial resources, setting financial goals, and fostering revenue growth. 

Selecting the right consultant might be just as important as comparing C corp vs S corp and picking one. It involves finding a professional who aligns with your specific needs, possesses relevant industry experience, and has a track record of addressing the challenges your business may encounter. Additionally, verifying necessary certifications and confirming strong management and leadership capabilities are essential steps in making this crucial decision.

Conclusion

In this blog, we have discussed the key differences in C corp vs S corp in terms of taxation, ownership, and operational aspects. Choosing between the two depends on factors like business size and long-term goals. Maintaining good record-keeping and consulting experts for the best fit is crucial.  

Are you ready to make a decision? Let us know in the comments if you’ll be starting an s corp or c corp, and why. 

When it comes to business or LLC, you want a reliable merchant processing experience. Acumen Connections is dedicated to helping businesses meet their goals. From finding the right credit card reader to saving money on processing fees, we’re the team merchants trust. Contact us to see how we can help your business today.